The marketing copy is clear: Rose Properties is ‘Green’ and develops properties according to the bylaws of those who think Green. I like that.
But “green” needs defining. I see no evidence of Green. That doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist and those with positions to know have given me some examples but I also see things which are contrary to green. Example: I have a long ago post about the air quality at Santa Cruz La Posada. (see The Inside Story of Indoor Air, located on this site.) It concentrates on overuse of cleaning chemicals.
Now comes a chance to be green as Rose Properties renovates La Posada of Santa Cruz. However they are not doing so with apartment flooring being replaced with PVC floors (chemicals polyvinyl chloride) in every kitchen, bathroom and hallway. Flooring to be used is here. And most apartments now in use have PVC flooring and for some reason they will be taken out even if only a year old. This causes toxic air as do the new floors installations. Polyvinyl chloride floors cannot be recycled.
A quick Google search finds this about polyvinyl flooring:
- Phthalates (Plasticizers). Added to soften rigid PVC plastic, phthalates like DEHP and DINP are not chemically bound to the material and can leach into household dust and indoor air over time. According to the Ecology Center, phthalates are endocrine disruptors linked to reproductive issues, developmental harms, and elevated asthma risks, particularly in infants and young children. [1]
- Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs). Newly installed vinyl flooring and installation adhesives release VOCs—such as formaldehyde, toluene, and benzene—through a process called off-gassing. Short-term inhalation can trigger headaches, dizziness, and eye or respiratory irritation, though off-gassing typically peaks within the first 72 hours and declines over one to two weeks.
First 72 hours to 2 weeks. Peak off-gassing happens right out of the box, creating a noticeable “new floor” chemical smell. Industry testing standards like FloorScore measure emissions at day 14, when levels stabilize to safer indoor limits. [1, 2, 3] Off gassing continues for months according to timelines found online reducing over time.
The particular flooring currently being installed at La Posada is a chemical flooring by Aladdin Flooring, named Forest Lawn 2.5. Opinion: Any name but that. This Forest Lawn does come with a label from FloorScore verifying the product follows CA indoor air emissions limits for manufacturing. The original Forest Lawn perhaps has a Led Zeppelin certification. (… “it’s whispered that soon if we all call the tune Then the piper will lead us to reason”)
How to begin life with PVC:
Minimize Exposure
- Choose certified products. Look for GREENGUARD Gold or FloorScore labels, which verify that the flooring meets indoor air emission limits.
- Use floating click-lock planks. Skipping glue-down vinyl eliminates the largest source of installation VOCs. (adhesives are the source of formaldyhde )
- Ventilate aggressively.
Keep windows open and run exhaust or HVAC fans continuously during installation and for the first 3 to 14 days. - Unbox planks early. Let new planks air out in a well-ventilated garage or covered outdoor area for 48 to 72 hours before bringing them inside.
WHAT’s the plan Rose Properties for Santa Cruz La Posada? Has your construction company met with residents to explain what they are going to be exposed to? Being over 62 and/or disabled makes a difference in how exposure affects respiration issues as well as those with autoimmune issues.
PVC flooring and its toxicity is becoming more well known. And so are alternatives. (a favorite word at La Posada – one of the entrees at dinner is always presented as “alternative” instead naming it.) This is a post on Reddit written by an architect:
Architect here, there is no type of safe vinyl/LVP flooring. It is very bad for the health of the planet, the people making it in factories, the people living near the factories, installers of vinyl, and end users as the material off gases and breaks down into microplastics. Some retailers have tried to pivot and sell recycled PVC, but this is probably even worse, as there have been studies shown that products with recycled pvc have elevated levels of heavy metals (from recycled electronics, car parts, and appliances getting mixed into the plastics). An easily digestible overview of alternatives and what to look our for is the Healthy Materials Lab’s flooring guide based out of New York City. I would highly recommend you consider other products like Linoleum, cork, ceramic tile, and solid bamboo / wood flooring. Engineered wood is very tricky on this subject because formaldehyde based adhesives are used to bind all the different layers together… however formaldehyde free options do exist (though they are few!).
Wrapping Up..
I present this info from research presented online. It’s always good to check it for yourself if so inclined. If you want to search online use key words such as PVC flooring, health concerns. Consider researching detox also. To all – A votre sante.
- Off-Gassing and VOCs: PVC can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) into the air over its lifecycle, potentially impacting indoor air quality.
Spectrum Floors +1
- Phthalates: Flexible PVC often relies on phthalate plasticizers to make it pliable, which can migrate out of the flooring into household dust and are known to disrupt hormones.
National Institutes of Health (NIH) | (.gov) +1
- Solid hardwood
- Natural linoleum (made from linseed oil and wood flour)
- Cork
- Bamboo
- Natural rubber flooring (labeled PVC-free)
- Ceramic or stone tile
Toxic-Free Future +1